Skip to main content

EVERYBODY HATES FRUIT CAKE


Today would have been my father’s 99th birthday, had he not died in 2004.  In his memory, I’m baking fruit cake, despite the fact that everybody says they hate fruit cake.  I’m using my mother’s recipe as an inspiration.  That’s her well-used recipe index card above.  She died in 1995, nine years before my father, leaving several fruitcakes in the freezer.  I inherited one of them, still wrapped in its Christmas wrapping paper shroud, in December 2004.  It came to a sad end in the Tiergarten, well, maybe not sad.  I like to think positively about the fate of that last fruitcake.  But you be the judge.
Weeping Willow and Japanese Maples in the Tiergarten
As fruitcakes go, mine was very well-traveled.  In early 2005, it was shipped overseas in a container along with furniture, housewares, Christmas ornaments, photographs, other emotionally-charged memorabilia, and odd whatnot's from my parents’ house in New Jersey to our house in Italy.  I imagine the fruitcake defrosted en route somewhere while crossing the Atlantic.  Because of this temperature-non-controlled journey, I was always afraid to eat it, yet I couldn’t bring myself to just throw it away.  So it remained re-frozen and untouched in our freezer in Tuscany for five years.  Then in July 2009, the last fruitcake traveled again, this time via a moving van to Berlin, during which trip it must have defrosted yet again, possibly somewhere outside of Leipzig.  But back into a new freezer it went on its arrival in Berlin, where it stayed until the winter of 2010.  
Tiergarten in the Fall
One very cold afternoon (was it February?), while pawing through the freezer in search of something, I saw the red, green, and gold Christmas paper-wrapped rectangular loaf.  Two options stared back at me.  One, I could throw caution to the wind and brave death or a severe case of the runs:  I could let it thaw, unwrap it, cut a slice, and eat it.  

Or, I could chicken out, be cautious, and figure out a way to dispose of it in a dignified manner befitting its sentimental origins, if not its longevity.  I chose Door Number Two. 
Lake in the Tiergarten
…which led to the Tiergarten.  One of the tricks my husband used to lure me from Tuscany to Berlin was the Tiergarten, a vast public park criss-crossed with canals, ponds, meadows, winding paths, formal flower gardens, imposing statuary of German cultural figures, charming stone bridges, and stands of mature trees planted after the war.  I love to walk and after we moved here, I went into the Tiergarten often.  One of my favorite spots is Am Neuen See, a small lake in the heart of the Tiergarten frequented by ducks, blue heron, and other assorted waterfowl.  

With the freezer door still open, I gently lifted the fruitcake out of its cryogenic home and carefully unwrapped it as if it were an Egyptian mummy.  I ceremoniously folded its Christmas shroud only to reveal a second protective layer--an inner aluminum foil protective wrapping.  With the heavy loaf in hand, hidden in a tote bag, I headed for Am Neuen See.  
Tiergarten in Winter Light
The lake was frozen over with ice that glared back at me in a slate gray indifference. Here and there were white scuffs on the surface where an animal had tread and left scrapings like those from a skater’s blade.  Near the shore broken black branches and dried reeds that grew at the water’s edge emerged from the depths.  Thankfully, I saw no bottles or cans, no evidence of human desecration.  But all that was about to change.
Blue Heron Am Neuen See
I solemnly removed the aluminum foil.  I stepped as close as I dared to the edge of the frozen lake.  I looked around and saw no one.  Just me and the last fruitcake.  Taking a deep breath and feeling a combination of shame and cowardice, I heaved the fruitcake as far across the lake as I could.  It hit the ice, bounced, did a triple Axel, skidded a bit, and finally slid to a resting stop about 50 meters from where I stood.  I felt ambivalent, but at least I hadn’t just “thrown it away.”  
My Fruit Cake Ingredients
You see, my plan was that hungry birds wintering in the Tiergarten or who knows, maybe even a fox or a marten, would find my mother’s last fruitcake and consume it hungrily, adding a little meat to their bones.  And it was also my fervent hope that any such consumption would not lead to botulism or worse.  I didn't return until Spring to find out, and by that time, the fruitcake was nowhere to be seen.  Had it been eaten?  Sunk to the bottom of the lake when it thawed?  I'll never know.

That’s my fruitcake confession.  
Before
In honor of my parents’ memory, at this time of the year when absence of family pierces particularly sharply, and perhaps to expiate guilt, I’m making my mother’s fruitcake.  And I don’t care that everybody hates fruitcake.  Well, I care just a little, which is why I decided to put my own stamp on it.  Truth be told, while my mother’s fruitcake was not the least bit dry (a common complaint among fruitcake haters), I always thought hers was a little too sweet, so I’m substituting dried cranberries for her red and green candied cherries, and I’m adding dates, citron, and a little candied ginger.  The candied pineapple, the walnuts, and the white and red raisins stay.  And, in a rash departure from my mother's recipe, I soaked all the fruit in a little brandy!  Judging by the wine (?) stains on the recipe index card, I think my mother would have approved.
After
Fruitcake.  You either love it or you hate it.  I loved my mother('s), so I made it. 

Keep it real!
Marilyn 

Comments

  1. Replies
    1. I'm soooo glad! Merry Christmas to you, Garr, E, and Dash!

      Delete
  2. Quel coincidence?? I'm making fruitcake today, the ne plus ultra of fruitcakes. 20 kinds of fruit, 3 kinds of peel, candied angelica and ginger, all soaked overnight in brandy; 6 kinds of nuts; ginger, cinnamon, and mace. They will be anointed with Cointreau on all sides after baking and wrapped up to mature for a few days. SO glad you're doing this, but I wish we could do it together. I loved searching for fruits at the German, Polish, Middle Eastern, Mexican groceries. This year I found mystery fruit at the Cremeria and raisins as big as my thumb at the Middle Eastern place. I love this kind of shopping.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Me too! It would have been almost as much fun as baking the Ayatollah Christmas Blasphemy Cookies.

      Delete
  3. My grandmother's recipe soaks the candied fruit and later douses the finished product with Jack Daniels. I've made it a few times and love it...but it's a lot of work, and not least is finding the black walnuts (English walnuts just don't cut it).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jack Daniels! Well, yee haw! That'll light up a smile.

      Delete
  4. I go back to the lake in the Tiergarten several times a year. But so far no fruitcake sightings. I know it will emerge, like something out of the Blue Lagoon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Marilyn,I went shopping today for the ingredients to "Emma's fruit cake." I have made it most Christmas's. Like you said either people love it or not and I have witnessed people taking the candied fruit and hiding it in the napkin. I think the apple sauce makes it moist . Your comments brought me to years, Christmas joy to you and Steve. We will miss spending this holiday with both of you. Love & kisses, Lynn and Hank

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hiding the candied fruit in their napkins! So many citron haters out there! Guess what. I screwed up the metric conversion and used TWICE the amount of butter as called for in my mother’s recipe. Definitely not a dry fruit cake! And quite the calorie bomb. Pretty darn tasty though. How did Aunt Emma’s turn out?

      Delete
  6. What a wonderful blog post! I hope the wildlife enjoyed the dried fruit in the loaf! You have a knack for bringing things to life when reading!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hold my Egg Nog for just a second.... I love a good fruit cake, P&L used to get them from some bakery in Texas. To me that was just about the best part of Christmas....although pecan pie and ice cream was neck and neck....

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

IN CASE OF EMERGENCY BREAK GLASS

A vocal critic of Benito Mussolini, Antonio Gramsci, Italian philosopher and politician,  was imprisoned for his political views in 1926; he remained in prison until shortly before his death in 1937.   From his cell, he wrote the  Prison Letters in which he famously said, “I’m a pessimist because of intelligence, but an optimist because of will."   In this time of upheaval, when the post-World War II world order is dying, a new world order is being born, and monsters roam the earth, it is from Gramsci's dual perspective that I write this post.    I will be brief. Th e window to oppose America’ s headlong rush into authoritarianism at home and neo-imperialism abroad by congressional or judicial means has closed.   Law firms, universities, businesses, the press, media, foundations, and individuals alike who have been deemed "insufficiently aligned" with the Administration's agenda, have been intimidated into submission by frivolous lawsuits, expe...

DISPUTING KEATS

The great English poet John Keats wrote in his magnificent 1819 poem, Ode on a Grecian Urn , “Beauty is truth, truth beauty,--that is all Ye know on earth, and all Ye need to know.”  Were that it were so!   But poetry cannot hide the fact that the truth is sometimes ugly.  Consider two current cases. First, the war in Gaza and the destruction and famine it has wrought.   Policy makers, scholars, and pundits can argue whether what is happening in Gaza (and to some extent, in the West Bank) is genocide, whether the leveling of Gaza and the systematic killing of its people is equivalent to the Holocaust, or whether Palestinians have the right to free themselves by any means necessary from an open-air prison.   They can debate whether Israel has become an apartheid, undemocratic state, or whether the only way to achieve security in Israel is to ring-fence or destroy Hamas. And they can construct theories about who has the “right” to live in historic Palestine, e...

THE IRON TRIANGLE

Corruption.   It’s like an operating system running in the background on the Computer of Life that inflects and infects everything we do and what is done to us.   Corruption is epidemic, endemic, and systemic. Universal, it is everywhere and all at once.   When he was the director of the FBI, Robert E. Mueller III gave an address to the Citizens Crime Commission of New York and opened a new window on the operating system of corruption:   transnational organized crime.   He called this new operating system an “iron triangle.” Its three sides:  organized criminals, corrupt government officials, and business leaders.    In her June 17, 2025, Substack , Heather Cox Richardson recalled Mueller’s address in an account of foreign investment in President Trump’s businesses.   She wrote: Eliot Brown of the Wall Street Journal reported that Mukesh Ambani, the richest man in India, is now one of the many wealthy foreign real estate develope...