![]() |
Very
disappointing! I’m a big fan of Gehry’s
and I’d heard nothing but rave reviews about the acoustics at the Pierre
Boulez. Moreover, I was curious about the
design of the hall itself. In November
of last year, we saw an architectural exhibition of two iconic concert hall
projects, one of which was by Gehry. The
exhibit was called Frank Gehry – Hans Scharoun: Strong Resonances. It celebrated the sister-city
partnership between Los Angeles and Berlin through rarely seen watercolors,
plans, original sketches, photographs, and models of the Berlin Philharmonic
(1960–63) designed by Hans Scharoun, and the Walt Disney Concert Hall in Los
Angeles (1999–2003) designed by Gehry (pictured above). The
exhibition also featured drawings for the Pierre Boulez Hall (2014-17). Scharoun’s influence on Gehry’s design was abundantly
clear, so I really wanted to go to the
concert tonight. Unfortunately, some earlier bird had beat me to it.
There are
interesting intersections (and divergences) between Scharoun and Gehry beyond
their shared architectural professions.
One unexpected intersection relates to modern German art. Both men were enamored of German Expressionism
and designed art installations for its display, albeit 60-70 years apart.
In the early 1920’s, Scharoun organized the first exhibition of the
German Expressionist group, Die Brücke,
in East Prussia. In 1983, Gehry designed
the exhibition at LACMA for the German
Expressionist Sculpture Exhibition and the installation in 1991-92, of the
landmark exhibition Degenerate Art: The
Fate of the Avant-Garde in Nazi Germany, which traveled to the Altes Museum
in Berlin. German Expressionism profoundly
influenced both men’s architectural styles. You can see that as plain as day in the Walt Disney Concert Hall above and in the Berlin Philharmonie below.
| Exterior Berlin Philharmonie |
One significant divergence in the men's backgrounds lies in race. Scharoun was a German, born in Bremen. He didn’t leave Germany during the Nazi era, as did many of his friends, and I don’t know if he was a member of the National Socialist Party. Gehry is a Jew born in Canada. He changed his surname from Goldberg to Gehry in 1956 in response to the antisemitism he endured as a child and as an undergraduate at the University of Southern California. It is a testimonial to art’s ability to bridge racial divides and link together two creative geniuses, one Jewish and the other not. Art is race-blind and democratic; it serves only beauty and the good inherent in all men.
Democratic
is an appropriate word to describe the interiors of the Berlin Philharmonie and
the Boulez Saal. I mentioned in the opening
paragraph that I was seeking a “front” seat for tonight’s concert. I put “front” in quotes because there is
actually no front in the Boulez Saal, nor
is there one in the Berlin Philharmonie.
Both concert halls have a centralized performance space with seating that
radiates up and out from the center. There are no bad seats in either hall and both offer a very intimate experience for the
concert goer.
![]() |
| Interior Pierre Boulez Saal |
![]() |
| Interior Berlin Philharmonie |
As a birthday
gift from Gehry I offer his thoughts on the creative process which I found
displayed on the wall at the Frank Gehry – Hans Scharoun: Strong Resonances exhibition:
Keep it real!



Apparently Gehry was also a fan of Germany and some of his iconic work we had a chance to see in Düsseldorf. Three buildings sit along the Rhine and anchor a fantastic new development which was the seed that grew into a whole new art/museum/entertainment/ office district. One that is loved both by the residents and by visitors who never realized his influence here in Deutschland.
ReplyDelete